5 Reasons Your Fingers Twitch How to Stop it for Good The Surprising Reasons Behind Your Finger Twitching Your Health Magazine Bats Garter Belt Yellow by Wyvern's Hoard Tingling in your thumb, index or middle finger? It could be Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Cause: Pressure on the median nerve in the wrist. Symptoms: Tingling Numbness Reduced grip strength My middle finger twitch a lot when I position the finger this way. Doesn't happen with other fingers LA87064, Bombshell Bat Costume By Leg Avenue